‘The Assassination Of Gianni Versace’ Is Disturbing, Excellent, And Absolutely Necessary

Andrew Cunanan‘s killing spree couldn’t have existed without silence. For four months in 1997, the serial killer claimed five victims, including the iconic fashion designer Gianni Versace. Cunanan wasn’t able to get away with these crimes because he was a master criminal. He was able to take so many lives largely because of an overprotective and unfocused police force that made countless major missteps and a media climate that didn’t care about a serial killer who targeted gay men until it was too late. It’s a story about the unspoken effects of silent discrimination. To this day, Versace’s murder is defined by silence. The murder of one of the first openly gay celebrities should be common knowledge instead of the often forgotten historic footnote it currently is. However, after the premiere of The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story, it will be next to impossible to forget the horrors of Versace’s murder.

Versace marks the second installment in Ryan Murphy‘s anthology series American Crime Story, and at first glance, it seems like an odd story to follow the groundbreaking The People V. O.J. Simpson. Though both criminal cases were defined by all-consuming amounts of media attention toward their end, Versace’s murder hasn’t stood the tests of modern history like O.J. Simpson’s trial has. In this way, Versace is a far more subtle season of the anthology series, dwelling longer in imagined conversations and alleged interactions than its predecessor ever did. But in every other way, Versace is the more direct season of the two. The series is one of the creepiest things Murphy has ever created, and it refuses to be ignored.

Almost all of Versace’s gripping yet unsettling elements can be attributed to Darren Criss‘ revolutionary performance as Andrew Cunanan. Criss brings an over-eager and rambling energy to the killer that initially starts as charming but then falls into the depths of being unhinged the more he lies. And FX’s version of Andrew lies a lot. From the series’ first episode, Andrew breathlessly drawls on about how vulgar he finds Versace’s designs before later obsessively tearing through every Versace ad and story he can get his hands on. As a viewer, it’s impossible to know what Andrew is thinking or motivated by at any given time, a choice that reflects the winding narrative of the book the Versace season is based on, Maureen Orth’s Vulgar Favors: Andrew Cunanan, Gianni Versace, and the Largest Failed Manhunt in U. S. History. That unhinged uncertainty also makes for one of the most disturbing performances we’ve seen on television in recent years.

In comparison, Édgar Ramírez’s take on the iconic Gianni Versace is defined by authenticity. Tragically and pointedly, Gianni Versace is the beating heart of this story. FX and Murphy portray the designer as a giving and wise man who understood the value of loving life, as well as his family. Seeing the designer teach his sister Donatella Versace (Penélope Cruz) about the emotion behind fashion and reassuring his partner Antionio D’Amico (Ricky Marty) about his deep love for him are two of the best parts of the series. There is light and goodness to this dark series. It’s evident even when Donatella and Antonio are at each other’s throats. However, it’s because the series works so hard to make Gianni Versace such an immediately endearing character that the Versace installment is so tragic.

This season doesn’t mince words, let alone actions. The first 10 minutes of the series painstakingly show Versace’s brutal murder, allowing the rest of the series to work backwards from that moment. If anything, it’s this format that prevents the second season of American Crime Story from ever feeling too exploitative. Versace seems obsessed with trying to figure out why these murders were allowed to go on for so long, sorting through Cunanan’s life in an attempt to find an answer. By the end of The Assassination of Gianni Versace, Andrew Cunanan doesn’t merely stand as Versace’s killer. He emerges as a terrifying monster who murdered five people who only wished him well. Likewise, Versace isn’t presented as just a talented designer. He emerges as a genius of his industry who was struck down far before his time. The saddest and most morbid note the series makes is how similar these two very different men truly were.

Versace is a deeply disturbing and emotionally confusing season of television. For every horrifying detail the series revels in, there is a beauty and sexiness that defines every one of its main characters. However, Versace does a few great things for this crime that have been sorely missing for a while. It gives names and faces to all of Cunanan’s victims, fully confronts the LGBT discrimination that was baked into this case, and it serves as a study of one of modern day history’s most chilling serial killers. The circumstances around Gianni Versace’s murder may have been categorized by silence, but American Crime Story’s take on Cunanan’s killing sprees is one of the loudest and boldest sagas on television.

Stream The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story on FXNOW and FX+