Jennifer Coolidge Didn’t Sleep With “200 Men” After ‘American Pie,’ but She Did Have One “Weird” Encounter

Jennifer Coolidge has shut down reports that she slept with “200 people” after filming American Pie. She says her comment, which she made months ago, was merely an exaggeration — however, she did have one “weird encounter” with a younger man (Girl, we’ve all been there).

Back in August, the actor told Variety that starring as Stifler’s Mom in the 1999 comedy helped spice up her love life. And one of the benefits was sex.

“You know, I got a lot of play being a MILF and I got a lot of sexual action from American Pie,” Coolidge told the outlet. “Just, you know what I mean, I’m just talking about — there were so many benefits to doing that movie.”

She added, “There would be like 200 people that I would never have slept with!” Well, that wasn’t exactly the case.

Coolidge set the record straight while being interviewed for Entertainment Weekly’s 2022 Entertainers of the Year, an accolade earned by her show-stopping performances in this year’s The Watcher and The White Lotus, the latter of which got her a Golden Globe nomination.

Ariana Grande joined Coolidge via Zoom (from England!! Where she’s filming Wicked!!!) to interview her for the feature. And the queen bee asked the question we’ve all been dying to hear since the Variety interview: “Do you remember the best dick you got from playing Stifler’s mom? Do you keep in touch?”

Coolidge began to answer by saying, “Well, it was definitely the youngest fellow. He was just very, very charming, and it was very weird because…” before Grande respectfully cut her off, insisting that there’s “no pressure to share the details.”

She’s truly a girl’s girl.

The White Lotus star said, “I’m glad you asked this” and explained that she did, indeed, make that joke to Variety.

“God, you really can’t make jokes in our town, because I did make the terrible mistake of saying, ‘Thank God for that movie, I got to sleep with 200 men,’ or whatever. And look, I would love to say that was true, but I mean, that was sort of an exaggeration — so I’m glad you’re asking me,” Coolidge told Grande.

She continued to explain that while she didn’t sleep with 200 men after the movie, it did bring her a few notable suitors: “But it did sort of open up the world to a much broader group of handsome men — and younger men. This one guy was particularly young — legal, of course, it was all very legal — but it was funny because we had to… The one moment was a little bit awkward because he…” she began to spill, before being cut off by Grande again (“I just wanted to make you laugh”).

“No, I won’t get into the details,” shared Coolidge. “But afterwards, the next morning, I told him I needed to get a blow dry. So he was so young, we called his mother to see where I could get a blow dry. It was so weird that happened on the phone, it was very clear that we were in the bed together.”

She ended her story by saying that she did, in fact, get a good recommendation… even if it involved her going to the “local mall.”

Stars, they’re just like us.