Andy Cohen Called Out By Ex-Boyfriend John Hill On ‘WWHL’: “That’s What Happens When You Let Your Ex-Boyfriend Be Behind The Bar”

Sure, Carrie Coon and Patton Oswalt were Andy Cohen‘s guests on Wednesday night’s (March 13) episode of Watch What Happens Live. But all attention turned to the bar when the host’s frequent collaborator (and ex-boyfriend) John Hill called him out for stealing his go-to karaoke song.

During a round of “Clubhouse Quickie,” Cohen revealed that his ideal karaoke song is John Denver’s “Rocky Mountain High” — but Hill, who appeared as the bartender on the episode, quickly reminded the Bravo boss who introduced him to the song.

“You stole it from me but it’s yours now,” Hill joked.

Cohen then owned up to his thievery. “I did steal that from you, oh my god. Wow,” he said upon his realization. “That’s what happens when you let your ex-boyfriend be behind the bar. He calls you out on everything.”

Hill and Cohen reportedly dated for three years before they ultimately broke up. Despite their split, the two have continued to work together on several projects. Hill, a former Broadway actor, currently serves as a producer on Watch What Happens Live. He also co-hosts SiriusXM’s Andy Cohen Live radio show alongside Cohen.

Back in 2020, Hill and Cohen opened up about their breakup when a fan asked what exactly happened during the former’s sold-out live show.

 “It was just time,” Hill said, before Cohen added, “We were in different places in our lives.”

Still, they were able to poke fun at each other in a game of “The Exlywed Game” — a play on the iconic Newlywed Game in which the two exes had to answer scandalous questions about each other. According to BravoTV, fans learned that Cohen once asked Hill to have a threesome and that there is, in fact, a sex tape of the two of them “floating around somewhere.”

Watch What Happens Live airs Sunday through Thursdays at 10 p.m. ET on Bravo. New episodes are available to stream the next day on Peacock.