Google apps
Main menu

Post a Comment On: Bruce Charlton's Notions

1 – 4 of 4
Blogger Wm Jas Tychonievich said...

I remember that when I was very young (preliterate), most abstract nouns were accompanied by very specific mental images. "World" for example, was associated with an image of a rainbow. "Devil" was a young man with curly black hair, laughing. "Miracle" was dark clouds with an orange sun shining through. "Welcome" was (oddly, but explicably) a Hopi kachina doll. "God" was this statue.

28 November 2017 at 10:20

Blogger Bruce Charlton said...

A kind of synaesthesia, perhaps? A phenomenon much commoner than realised - probably quite natural and spontaneous.

(Interestingly, this phenomenon was mentioned on a recent episode of the Big Bang Theory sit-com that I watched yesterday, by the 'genius' character Sheldon. Some kind of synaesthesia seems very common among creative geniuses - indeed, I would expect this; given that creativity comes from a greater domination of thinking by the 'inner'.)

28 November 2017 at 10:55

Blogger Wm Jas Tychonievich said...

I know where some of these come from. The "miracle" picture was on the cover of a book by parents used to read to me, which explained how many things worked and then ended each explanation with "...but you wouldn't understand that, so to you it's a miracle."

The "welcome" image came from the children's song "Book of Mormon Stories," specifically the line "Lamanites met others who were seeking liberty / And the land soon welcomed all who wanted to be free." I heard "welcomed all" as "welcome doll" and, perhaps because of the "Lamanite" context, pictured the Welcome Doll as a particular kachina doll I had seen in a book called "The Indian Book." Even now the word "welcome" sometimes conjures up the image of that doll.

I suspect most synaesthesia originates in similar long-forgotten links. There was a study a few years back on how many cases of color-letter synaesthesia can be traced to the color schemes of alphabet fridge magnet sets.

Your name, Bruce, by the way, is associated with the image of a dark-faced man in long blue robes. Ages ago my dad had two colleagues he used to talk about, Bruce and Val; I never met either, but for some reason mapped both names to the same blue-robed image. I have no idea where it came from.

28 November 2017 at 14:27

Blogger Bruce Charlton said...

@WmJas - I expect something like that explanation is correct about synaesthesia - at least, most of the time.

I know somebody for whom very specific shades of a colour are linked with individual-people (not their names) - another famous example of colour synaesthesia was the composer Scriabin.

With reference to my name, up to about age six or seven, I felt a connection with anybody who shared my name. I didn't know many, but there was a motor racing driver called Bruce Maclaren, and an 'entertainer' Bruce Forsyth. And of course Robert The Bruce (as you probably knowm Bruce was a *Norman* surname... spit).

In my teens Monty Python did a sketch about stereotypical outback Australians called Bruce; and from then I had to suffer being quoted excerpts of this sketch (and/ or the accompanying 'philosophers song') every time I was introduced.

But nowadays there are loads of world famous Bruces - so I seldom even notice the name - certainly I don't favour it.

28 November 2017 at 15:28