Google apps
Main menu

Post a Comment On: Bruce Charlton's Notions

1 – 7 of 7
Anonymous Junger said...

I think a lot of people would agree with you, except that your use of "demons" as a corporeal, literal group (at least that sounds like what you're endorsing here in this post) sounds a little bit too much like David Icke for most people. This is my first time commenting here (and I will read through your backlog), but just for clarity's sake, do you believe that Hillary et. al. are lizard people? Also, since Trump is opposing some of this insanity, and yet himself is obviously pretty secular, where do you place him on the good-evil continuum?

26 July 2016 at 07:53

Blogger David Balfour said...

This perspective seems very compatible with Lewis' Screwtape letters. Similar arguements supporting the demonic benefits of humans having long, comfortable lives in which their is a greater long-term potential to corrupt instead of losing the many souls who might otherwise repent spontanteously in a world collapse situation, at which point the mechanisations of crude evil would be nakedly obvious to the population at large. Sleep-walking is much more effective.

26 July 2016 at 10:45

Blogger Bruce Charlton said...

@Junger - The belief that demons are active in this world, and that there is a spiritual warfare between them and God, has been mainstream Christian belief ever since the beginning (just look at the New Testament) - and remains so among all real Christians. The description that most modern people know best is CS Lewis's The Screwtape Letters; which must be taken as a fictionalised account of reality.

So that is a given. Specific identifications of specific people is another matter - and not necessary since it is clear enough who is on which side nowadays.

So far as I can tell, *all* mainstream and influential political figures in The West are (on average, net) on the demonic side pretty strongly (and thus against Christianity as an organising principle for life) - although of course in each person there is a mixture of motivations and nobody is wholly evil (not least because that is an impossibility since it would mean the negation of everything).

Is that clear enough?

26 July 2016 at 11:55

Blogger Bruce Charlton said...

@David - yes indeed; although as I said a couple of weeks ago, we cannot be sleep-walked *all* the way to damnation, but only to its threshold.

There will necessarily and always be a *moment* when the sight clears and reality is shown to every individual so that they can, will and must make a choice.

Of course, if you have gone through life (in effect) training yourself to reject Good - then even when (after death) you are shown it lucidly, and offered it on a plate, there will be a danger that you reject it and choose damnation.

This is (I believe) a greater risk in the modern West than ever at any time or place before - since the most ignorant and brutal pre-modern pagan of the past or elsewhere will innately have the common sense to take the gift of a good eternal deal when it is sure and certain - it takes a special kind of 'training' in inversion, to fail to perceive the obvious in the way that our civilisation now does.

(How this works can be seen among the dwarfs at the end of CS Lewis's The Last Battle, or in The Great Divorce.)

26 July 2016 at 12:03

Blogger Aurini said...

You nailed it, Mr Charlton. I expect I'll be writing a response post soon, I've been doing quite a bit of meditation on "my mission" and I think you've helped me find a way of explaining things that doesn't reek of narcissism.

This is why I have trouble getting on board with the "Remove Kebab" sentiment. While some speak out of righteous anger, many speak out of wrath. It is not a Papal-ordained movement that Deus Vult, but rather an excuse to indulge in despite and to raise up our own sins as virtues (celebrating homosexuality because the migrants go to the opposite extreme).

Also, Junger - for what it's worth, a major step in my conversion was realizing that ignorance, mental illness, and short-term self interest - while they explained much of what I saw in the world - fell short of explaining it all. I was eventually forced to conclude that there is a supernatural conspiracy of utter evil behind it all - that Uncle Screwtape is real - and that devils are very active upon the Earth.

I believed in Satan far before I came to have faith in God.

26 July 2016 at 16:09

Anonymous Brett Stevens said...

Great piece. It seems to me that the demonic is more simpler than I gave it credit for: it is simply that which wishes to lower all above it to its own level, which is pathological individualism through hubris. For this reason, our elites are like any other vermin. They infest and ruin, in order to make a comfortable environment for themselves, since they have already given their souls over to resentment, bitterness, rationalization and other weakness.

26 July 2016 at 16:36

Blogger 360 Decrees said...

So, no need to fear all-out nuclear exchange, at least not until it's time to stick a fork in us.

I was preoccupied back in the '70s with what I took to be either the imminent collapse of Western Civilization or the shifting of power to the Second World or an ecological catastrophe. It seemed to me that some terrible thing might happen in the late '70s, the '80s, or the '90s.

On the other hand, during moments of youthful optimism and belief that there could be harmony between Christianity and scientific Utopias, I imagined that man could forge a truly mature civilization and bring on a long period of peace. The End Times would come as a reward.

I even had the music picked out for it. Not Bruckner for this Apocalypse, but soft tremoloing strings to evoke the long peace and a languid horn for the last trump:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=erOEatu5aH8

(The string intro is cut off in this excerpt and the horn is less prominent, but it still conveys the impression.)

27 July 2016 at 06:46