Items that are unread and starred only show the star icon

[blackketter]

If an item is both unread and starred, only the star is shown. Both tags should be shown in that case. In lists it appears that there's enough room for both icons to appear on the left side, one above the other.

Alternatively, the yellow star and blue circle could be stacked to show both tags. This approach could be extended if additional tags are added later, as is done in the Finder