Kylie Jenner and Stassie Karanikolaou Taste Test 6 Types of Wings, Fries and 5 Crumbl Cookies: 'I’m Getting Ill!'

Kylie Jenner and her longtime bestie Stassie Karanikolaou brought Hot Ones home.

The social media stars sat down for a Wingstop taste test in an Instagram post shared on Thursday, June 27. “The mukbang girls are back!” the Kylie Cosmetics founder, 26, exclaimed while sitting next to Karanikolaou, 27.

Jenner was a little overzealous, almost taking a bite before Karanikolaou interrupted her, saying that they had to “get ready” first with some ranch. After the pair take their bites, Karanikolaou asked The Kardashians star if she knew what the flavor was. Jenner narrowed her eyes in thought but said that she didn’t know.

“Garlic parmesan!” Karanikolaou sing-songed before the pair did a little dance, agreeing that it was tasty. “Love garlic parmesan. 10 out of 10,” Jenner rated, adding that it was “a little spicy.”

For the second taste test, Jenner examined the wing and said it was “giving sweet and sour” but Karanikolaou corrected her and said it was mango habanero.

The pair’s decade-long friendship was evident in their sisterly banter, especially when there was a mess made during their tasting. “You just spilled some of your chicken juice on my leg,” Jenner laughed before giving her review of the second flavor. “This one is too spicy.”

While Karanikolaou left the room to get a napkin, the founder of Khy clothing line gave viewers a look inside her order.

“You guys have to see this,” she said, laughing so hard she could barely get out her words while showing the camera the numerous cups of ranch in the bag. “Why did she get so much ranch?”

Jenner looked closely at the next wing and guessed that it was lemon pepper but Karanikolaou confirmed that it was cajun. “This is amazing,” said Jenner. “Why have I not been going to Wingstop?”

After four flavors of boneless chicken wings, Jenner stepped out of the frame and returned with two drinks. “I mean, it’s almost 5,” Jenner said as she handed Karanikolaou a can of Sprinter, her recently released spiked seltzers.

“See, Stas and I weren’t feeling good yesterday and all we needed was each other,” Jenner added as the two cuddled up next to each other.

Next up, they tried the Louisiana rub wings but their bright red color spooked Jenner. “I’m just going to take a little bite, this seems insane,” Jenner said. Ultimately, they agreed that it didn’t taste as spicy as it smelled.

“Best for motherf---ing last,” Karanikolaou said as the pair held up the lemon pepper wings. After saying “cheers” with the chicken and taking a bite, the two immediately cooed. “These are fire,” Jenner said.

The wing taste test was just the first part of the pals’ snacking session.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. 

Jenner posted a video of them trying Crumbl cookies after she had been “begging Stas to eat more Crumbl cookies" with her. Just like the chicken-focused clip, the content creators shimmied with joy when they thought a cookie was particularly tasty. They tried flavors like semi-sweet chocolate chunk, lemon cupcake, honey bun and peanut butter and jelly.

“I think we’re done here,” Jenner said, trying to cut the dessert segment short against Karanikolaou’s protests. “I’m getting ill! We just had so many wings!”

But Karanikolaou agreed, "I'm going to throw up!"

Despite the stomachaches, they trudged on and tried the last sweet — the butter cake cookie — and agreed it was their favorite.

“Let us know what we should eat next!” Jenner concluded the video before blowing a kiss to the camera.