Meet the Real-Life Loves and Children of the American Pie Cast

Alyson Hannigan's Husband, Alexis Denisof

Actors Alyson Hannigan (American Pie's Michelle) and Alexis Denisof had a very Hollywood meet-cute on the set of Buffy the Vampire Slayer in the late '90s. Hannigan, now 50, starred on the series as the witch Willow, and Denisof, now 58, played the watcher Westley Wyndam-Price. Hannigan once said it was “flirtation at first sight.”

The stars wed in 2003, and have since welcomed two daughters, Satyana Marie and Keeva Jane. They've also shared the screen on other pop culture favorites, including her series How I Met Your Mother.

Eugene Levy's Wife, Deborah Divine

Eugene Levy and producer Deborah Divine have been together since the 1970s, and have expanded their show business family with son Dan, daughter Sarah and grandson James.

When Levy, now 77, won the outstanding lead actor in a comedy series Emmy Award for Schitt's Creek in 2020, his first thank-you was to his wife, "for all the love, support and sage counsel over the years. I wouldn't be up here without you, Deb," he continued. "I love you."

Jason Biggs' Wife, Jenny Mollen

Jason Biggs, 46, and bestselling author Jenny Mollen, 45, wed in 2008 and went on to welcome sons Lazlo and Sid in the years following.

The pair often collaborates on projects (and sweet, cheeky Instagrams!), most recently partnering for the TBS series Dinner and a Movie and Mollen's podcast, All the Fails.

Shannon Elizabeth's Husband, Simon Borchert

Shannon Elizabeth (who played Nadia) and brand strategist Simon Borchert share not only a passion for each other, but for the environment. Though they don't often speak publicly about their relationship, the pair work together through her namesake foundation to protect rhinos and strengthen conservation efforts through "engaging with legislators," according to an episode of The Do One Better podcast. Elizabeth, 50, and Borchert have also hosted a podcast together, The Art of Conservation.

Chris Klein's Wife, Laina Rose Thyfault

In 2015, Chris Klein (a.k.a. Oz) and travel agent Laina Rose Thyfault, now 39, tied the knot in front of 115 guests during an outdoor ceremony at the Rainbow Ranch in Montana.

“Promising forever was definitely the highlight,” the actor, 45, told PEOPLE. “Nothing gets better than that.”

The couple now has two children, daughter Isla and son Frederick.

John Cho's Wife, Kerri Higuchi

John Cho ('MILF Guy'), now 52, and fellow actor Kerri Higuchi married in 2006, during her stint on Grey's Anatomy. Together, the private couple shares two children, one boy and one girl, according to Us Weekly.

Natasha Lyonne's Rumored Boyfriend, Bryn Mooser

Though neither of them have said anything to confirm a relationship, for the past several months, Natasha Lyonne (who played Jessica), 45, and producer Bryn Mooser, 44, have been spending time together, walking the red carpet at the 2024 Golden Globes, sitting side-by-side for Macaulay Culkin's Walk of Fame ceremony and posting snuggly Instagrams.

Tara Reid's Boyfriend, Nathan Montpetit-Howar

In 2019, Tara Reid (who played Vicky) went Instagram official with boyfriend and music producer Nathan Montpetit-Howar while they were on vacation in Mexico. In the years since, Reid, now 48, and Montpetit-Howar have remained prominent on each other's feeds and made a handful of public appearances together.

Mena Suvari's Husband, Michael Hope

In another cute Hollywood moment, Mena Suvari (Heather), 45, met artist Michael Hope on the set of the 2016 Hallmark movie I'll Be Home for Christmas. She starred in the holiday project, while Hope worked in the art department.

Two years after meeting, the couple married in an intimate ceremony in 2018, and later welcomed their first child, son Christopher, in 2021.