“May December,” Todd Haynes’s tenth feature, spins a profoundly layered psychological drama from potentially cheap tabloid copy: the true-life scandal of Mary Kay Letourneau, a schoolteacher and married mother of four who began a sexual affair with one of her sixth-grade students. Samy Burch’s script fictionalises the story into a complex study of female mirroring, starring Natalie Portman as an A-list actress preparing to play Julianne Moore’s Letourneau-like pariah. 

At the Zurich Film Festival, Haynes dropped into the Variety Lounge to explain why he was instantly intrigued by Burch’s script after Portman passed it to him — and how it eventually became his fifth collaboration with Moore, his eternal muse. “The way [Natalie] talked about the moral gray areas that we both were intrigued by reminded me of somebody I know very well,” he recalls. Moore, he says, is “drawn to these kinds of characters that unnerve us, that perplex us, that are hard to reach, to fully assess” — “May December” played right into that dark sweet spot.

He’s amused by the number of critics referring to the film as camp, or soap opera-adjacent, having instead taken inspiration from such European arthouse masters as Ingmar Bergman and Jean-Luc Godard: “It was not anything that I was trying to do at all, and when you watch the film, there’s a very austere, restrained camera through so much of it.” 

As a queer filmmaker, meanwhile, he’s disheartened by the current political era: “If anything, we’re back to the conservative voice that I confronted in my first film.” And confront it he will in his next project, a gay interracial love story set in 1930s Los Angeles starring Joaquin Phoenix — Haynes reveals more in our conversation.

Watch the full conversation above.

\