Google apps
Main menu

Post a Comment On: Bruce Charlton's Notions

1 – 4 of 4
Blogger Jared said...

From this quotes it would appear that belief is primary. Even the summary or last quote emphasizes that point.
The quote that says 'whoso eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood' or similar words also appears to be related to belief. So belief is really important to our eternal destiny.

21 July 2019 at 22:49

Blogger Bruce Charlton said...

@Jared - Well there cannot be a true separation; but for modern people I think it may be more natural and comprehensible first step to think of the nature of Heavenly Life and (setting aside at first whether they believe it is real) consider whether it is, for them, a desired destiny.

If resurrected immortality as active participants in a loving and creative environment is something that they would desire to have for themselves (and their loved ones), then at that point they can consider whether it is true, whether possible, what to do etc.

And that could be 'where Jesus comes in'.

Of course, for some people love, faith and trust in Jesus can and does come first; but that way of explaining has been around a long time, and apparently it does not work for many people.

Also, there is the example of Jesus himself. A fair bit of his teaching in the fourth Gospel focuses on 'explaining' (in parables and 'poetic' comparisons) the nature of Heaven and its qualitative superiority to mortal life, and doing so as it were Before he explains that He Himself is the path to this Heavenly life.

21 July 2019 at 23:14

Blogger David Smith said...

And an actionable definition of "Believe in Me" is, in a nutshell...and here I get stuck. Believe that He lived, died, rose, and ascended? Believe that he is the Second Person of the Holy Trinity? Believe that He can give me eternal life in a risen state?

John 14:15 (If you love me, keep my commandments) seems more actionable, as long as I correctly parse and interpret which of the Master's statements are commandments. I can certainly take a shot at that, and get no end of suggestions, even if I limit myself to the Gospel attributed to John.

I am utterly and entirely sincere in asking this...

22 July 2019 at 00:39

Blogger Bruce Charlton said...

@DS - You might read my mini-book Lazarus Writes to get a fuller explanation of what this means - https://lazaruswrites.blogspot.com/ - but you will also need to examine your own assumptions concerning the nature of the world; and recognise that it is your unexamined assumptions that make you feel that these words are false or irrelevant.

For example, Believe (for Jesus) is a complex and multiple word, more like a word in poetry than a technical term. It is like a child 'believing-in' his mother - this means something like loving, trusting, *knowing* that his mother loves him and has his best interests at heart; so that (n practice) he will do what his mother says even when he does not understand. It is in this kind of sense that we need to Follow Jesus; but as adults we must consciously choose to do so.

This entails that we need experience of a personal relatinship with Jesus, and must believe that this is possible and meaningful - whereas to most modern people that is nonsense (although a relationship with a divine being has Not been nonsense to most people who have ever lived, or to most people in the world even now).

And 'commandments' - you probably think of these as being like laws, or military orders; to be (passively) obeyed. But the concept is actually much broader. But Jesus (in the Fourth Gospel) gradually makes clear that this is wrong, that commandments to love cannot be understood as 'commands' - because real love cannot be compelled; but are something more like the basic principles that we must actively choose to live-by.

Ultimately we each must choose whether or not to align our-selves with God and creation. But before that choice can be meaningful, we need to know what is 'on offer'; and that has become impossible to understand for those who accept the materialism, positivism, scientism of mainstream modern life.

In other words, you - like most people - are trapped by several false assumptions, which you do not even realise are assumptions; you simply take them for granted or imagine they are 'proven facts'. Because there are *several* false assumptions, they cannot coherently be challenged one at a time; but you must develop a complex and multiple simultaneous insight. A kind of 'conversion'.

And only you can do this, and it must actively be done.

22 July 2019 at 06:41