Google apps
Main menu

Post a Comment On: Bruce Charlton's Notions

1 – 6 of 6
Anonymous dearieme said...

If ever I have a spiritual crisis, whatever that may be, I'll want to hear from a parson about God and me. If he starts up with flummery about bloody elves and leprechauns - aka angels, saints and whatnots - he'll lose the chance of hauling in this unbeliever.

29 October 2012 at 15:20

Blogger Bruce Charlton said...

@d - that's the Scots Puritan talking...

I certainly do not believe that an active belief in Angels and Saints is necessary to salvation (or else I would have to reject nearly all post-Reformation Christianity, which would be nonsense) - but an *abstract* belief in A & S is scriptural (hence *is* necessary), an *active* belief in A and S is not forbidden, and an active belief in A & S is very helpful (to sanctification/ theosis) for some people - probably most people, in fact.

29 October 2012 at 15:48

Anonymous Anonymous said...

When my sons were small my wife and I used to joke that their guardian angels must be exhausted at the end of day protecting them from mishap after another.

31 October 2012 at 03:00

Anonymous Samson J. said...

Protestants usually believe in the reality of angels, in an abstract kind of way, but seldom or never think about their reality because they do not find any use for them in their spiritual lives

I believe in their active agency because I think I might have met one once. But that is a personal story.

If he starts up with flummery about bloody elves and leprechauns - aka angels, saints and whatnots - he'll lose the chance of hauling in this unbeliever.

If there's one thing I know about God, it's that he has a habit of humbling us by using means we would have considered RIDICULOUS or contemptuous to teach us important lessons; and the number of Christians who in their former lives said "I will NEVER..." is high as the heavens!

31 October 2012 at 14:20

Blogger Bruce Charlton said...

@SJ - Absolutely.

As an active proselytizing atheist from age 6- about 49 I know exactly how absurd and pathetic my born-again conversion looks to those who are now, the same as I was then.

But it happened to me, so it could happen to (almost) anyone...

31 October 2012 at 14:24

Anonymous Samson J. said...

As an active proselytizing atheist from age 6

This post is getting low in the queue, so perhaps no one will be around anymore, but this is another one of my perennial favourite topics: it seems that many, many of us in the high-IQ crowd became atheists at the age of less than 10 - and refused to ever question this decision even when we reached adulthood.

I don't know about you, but as a general rule I would say that it's probably a good idea, once you become an adult, to re-evaluate things that you thought were crystal clear when you were 6. But atheists so often don't; they think that their youthful (de-)conversion was perfectly reasonable.

In fact, I don't even know where we get the *idea* of "atheism" when we're that age. I can remember walking home with a school friend and telling him I didn't believe in God - where did I get that idea at the age of 8? They don't discuss atheism on cartoon shows, after all! To me it shows that we are spiritual creatures (and fallen ones!) the whole way along.

31 October 2012 at 19:14