Google apps
Main menu

Post a Comment On: Bruce Charlton's Notions

1 – 12 of 12
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Mr. Charlton,

My experience of the coronavirus has not been as Satanically bleak as you suggest, and I do not think that it is unique. I live in California, a state in "lockdown," but it doesn't feel like much of a lockdown. This morning I went running at a local trail. There were lots of people there; not any less than usual. My family went for a walk in the park on Saturday. I've noticed an increase in neighborly friendliness. I've spoken with neighbors now that I've never spoken with before. There is a sense in which everyone is in this together, and it has helped to bring greater solidarity. The fact that families are spending more time at home means that they are having to connect with one another in ways that they haven't in awhile. The bureaucratic managerial class may have meant this for evil, but God has meant it for good.

Respectfully,

Drew

25 March 2020 at 19:16

Blogger Bruce Charlton said...

@Drew - We need to be able to separate our own subjective response to the situation today, from an objective understanding of where the situation is planned to go by those who have created it. If you read this blog, you will see that I try to keep these distinct.

25 March 2020 at 19:26

Blogger Ingemar said...

Bruce,

If this crisis doesn't result in the mass of general humanity abandoning the mainstream and social medias, we really deserve what's coming to us next.

25 March 2020 at 21:08

Anonymous Anonymous said...

I also live in California and my sense is different than Drew's. Yes, people are being friendlier than usual, but once this "lockdown" is extended longer I think the mood may change.

Today the "health officers" working with the "county superintendents" extended the school closures to May 1 for 7 counties of the San Francisco Bay Area where I live. Businesses deemed "non-essential" (such as salons, for instance) will likely be closed for that length of time too. Who gave the "health officers" such power to make these decisions?

Unemployment claims in California since March 13 have reached 1 million. How long can people not work, and live off little to no savings, without triggering an economic depression, not to mention actual depression?

Parking lots of many parks have been closed by government officials due to too many people congregating in parks and beaches. Churches are closed. If my own kids and family are going a bit stir-crazy, I can only imagine what this will do overall to people's mental health.

What will government do if people decide they've had enough, and just start opening their businesses? How are governments going to stop them? Mass arrests of thousands? Issue fines which can be ignored or challenged in court?

Some people are beginning to question why government employees and politicians are earning salaries while small businesses are laying people off and living off meager savings. Others may go bankrupt.

Evil disguised as altruism. "We need to destroy people's livelihood to save people from this virus. If you don't agree, you must want to kill people!"

KatM

25 March 2020 at 22:29

Blogger Brief Outlines said...

Very well put,and quite uncanny; I made this very connection myself only 24 hours ago - almost word for word.

25 March 2020 at 23:13

Anonymous Jeb said...

I will be very interested to see how it turns out for Mexico and Brazil or any other country whose leaders are saying this is media hype and to continue life almost as normal. I certainly hope we get some leading minds who never give up analyzing this event for many years to come.

25 March 2020 at 23:22

Blogger Ugh said...

Respectfully, Drew that's awfully shortsighted.

Bruce, this is exactly what I been feeling but could not express. My wife is wondering why I'm so negative and depressed by all this - she thinks the politicians are doing the right thing. I guess I see a bigger picture. Even if this passes it will be so easy for them to do it again for 'righteous' reasons and we the sheeple will just go along.

26 March 2020 at 00:58

Blogger a_probst said...

@Ingemar

At the very least as punishment for chronic bad taste.

26 March 2020 at 02:32

Blogger Wm Jas Tychonievich said...

Ingemar, there's no chance of that at all. People will be glued to the news to keep up with the latest developments in the birdemic story, and social media will be almost the only "social" option for those under house arrest.

26 March 2020 at 03:07

Blogger Lucinda said...

One thing I find particularly sinister is the supposed self-sacrifice, supposed pro-lifeness of it all. Meanwhile the fertility rate will be further driven into the ground, sacrificing those with the most life and potential to the fake idea of saving the lives of those with the least. We are now told to believe in their self-sacrifice of freedom for the lives of others, oh how noble they are! They are not acting out of fear! They say.

The incredible hypocrisy and virtue-signaling are still so amazing to me.

26 March 2020 at 16:11

Blogger Bruce Charlton said...

@Lucinda - I have been writing for several years that this is the most cowardly society in history (this deriving from my - futile - involvement over twenty-some years in 'activism' against bureaucracy and corruption in medicine and universities. But even I have been surprised (and embarrassed) by the degree and prevalence of cowardice on public display at present; made the worse by preening self-righteousness. Too cowardly to admit cowardice, in fact. By such means, as so often, Modern Man closes off even the possibility of repentance.

26 March 2020 at 16:23

Blogger Ingemar said...

Wm Jas Tychonievich:

Of course not. The Plan all along was to get people atomized, afraid, and wholly dependent on the Father of Lies for "truth." Even now, though I am still working, I am doing so under house arrest and am compelled to spend half an hour a day discussing the Birdemic.

My, our, only hope is that Almighty God shall show His enemies the strength of His arm. Whether today or some unspecified moment in the future.

26 March 2020 at 17:59