Google apps
Main menu

Post a Comment On: Bruce Charlton's Notions

1 – 3 of 3
Blogger Jacob Gittes said...

I was just out in Montana to camp in the Badlands. Beautiful there.
Anyway, it would seem that in Montana, life goes on almost pre-birdemic. It was quite jarring, but welcome.
Of course, there are the more educated and "in-time" with the evil system types who are outliers there, but in general, it was interesting to see that reality can really diverge so much on a material level.
To see kids on bikes in the street together. Old men chatting over coffee or beer, not social distancing. It's almost like a force field must exist around certain areas.

The virus thing is so boring that I almost go into some kind of fugue state when I hear it discussed on the radio or TV (which is rarely, and only if someone else has it on).

If reality and people were as I thought they were, how could anyone tolerate constant chatter about ONE single subject, constantly, day and and day out, without just having some kind of mental break?

22 May 2020 at 14:17

Blogger Bruce Charlton said...

@B - That is the kind of question we should not waste our time on - how the heck could anyone know who lacked specific genuine expertise, clinical experience, and honesty - as well as specific motivation? (This combination is extremely rare - and maybe no single person alive fulfils the criteria.) No real therapeutic discovery has ever been made via the mass media.

22 May 2020 at 17:35

Blogger lgude said...

Yes, I've been noticing that I've become bored - even though it is clear enough at age 77 with a compromised heart that I would probably blow a gasket if I got it. But so what? I've already exceeded my 3 score and ten and have to die in any case. Still, I do find myself interested by the times we live in for exactly the reasons you give. Evil is well and truly on the loose and a great upheaval is underway, but whether I watch it from this life or the next is not up to me. I think we have passed this way before and I have a newfound appreciation for Augustine's long embrace of Manichaeism - one could easily see the current struggle between good and evil as equally balanced in the absence of our connection to God.

24 May 2020 at 05:57