I've been meaning to post this. Your posts come so fast and furious and are so full of meaning to me, that I barely have time to reflect and comment. (Please don't take that as an injuction to post less frequently! I really gain spiritual nourishment from this blog, and I have very few other sources in my life, sad as that might sound!)
I've never seen Blade Runner, apart from a few pop-culture references here and there. But I'm happy to see that your other two choices are two of my favorite scene! The Ride of the Rohirrim is glorious indeed, but so much of Tolkien is glorious then. The end of the Last of the Mohicans is something I've watched so many times I have lost count. The overlapping greatness of the characters is heart-crushing in the best possible sense: the nobility of Duncan sacrificing himself; the pity and compassion and skill that lets Hawkeye kill Duncan; the chivalry of Uncas as he charges off to save Alice even as he pays obeisance to his brother and father; the simple acknowledgment among the three Mohicans that Hawkeye is the best shooter, and the humble, simple way he accepts this truth. The killing charge through the Huron guards of Magwa; the bravery of Uncas in his confrontation with Magwa; the hopeless suicide of Alice and the devastation of her sister. The righteous rage of Chinganchgook, and the ultimate victory-through-terrible-pain of Hawkeye and Chinganchgook: all of this makes me shiver every time I watch it! (Which, as you can tell, is often!)
Glad to see I am backed up by such an informed commenter!
15 July 2011 at 16:24
Anonymous said...
The Lord of the Rings trilogy is excellent (I have read the books too) but, regarding pseudo-medieval fantasies, I prefer "Excalibur", a modern rendering of the King Arthur fables.
Unlike LOTR, an undercurrent of melancholy runs through "Excalibur": the awareness that time passes, that good times are fleeting, people get old and die but ideals remain.
A lot of Christian and conservative concepts are in the movie: how one sin destroys an entire country (a metaphor of the Fall), the quest of the Good (the Holy Grail), the loyalty of people toward their King, etc.
I saw it on release and a couple of times since, but Excalibur doesn't work for me - although I am something of a fan of Nicol Williamson (who was the best Hamlet I have ever seen).
"My three favourite movie scenes: fighting, courage, acceptance of mortality..."
4 Comments -
Dr. Charlton,
I've been meaning to post this. Your posts come so fast and furious and are so full of meaning to me, that I barely have time to reflect and comment. (Please don't take that as an injuction to post less frequently! I really gain spiritual nourishment from this blog, and I have very few other sources in my life, sad as that might sound!)
I've never seen Blade Runner, apart from a few pop-culture references here and there. But I'm happy to see that your other two choices are two of my favorite scene! The Ride of the Rohirrim is glorious indeed, but so much of Tolkien is glorious then. The end of the Last of the Mohicans is something I've watched so many times I have lost count. The overlapping greatness of the characters is heart-crushing in the best possible sense: the nobility of Duncan sacrificing himself; the pity and compassion and skill that lets Hawkeye kill Duncan; the chivalry of Uncas as he charges off to save Alice even as he pays obeisance to his brother and father; the simple acknowledgment among the three Mohicans that Hawkeye is the best shooter, and the humble, simple way he accepts this truth. The killing charge through the Huron guards of Magwa; the bravery of Uncas in his confrontation with Magwa; the hopeless suicide of Alice and the devastation of her sister. The righteous rage of Chinganchgook, and the ultimate victory-through-terrible-pain of Hawkeye and Chinganchgook: all of this makes me shiver every time I watch it! (Which, as you can tell, is often!)
15 July 2011 at 13:42
Glad to see I am backed up by such an informed commenter!
15 July 2011 at 16:24
The Lord of the Rings trilogy is excellent (I have read the books too) but, regarding pseudo-medieval fantasies, I prefer "Excalibur", a modern rendering of the King Arthur fables.
Unlike LOTR, an undercurrent of melancholy runs through "Excalibur": the awareness that time passes, that good times are fleeting, people get old and die but ideals remain.
A lot of Christian and conservative concepts are in the movie: how one sin destroys an entire country (a metaphor of the Fall), the quest of the Good (the Holy Grail), the loyalty of people toward their King, etc.
Imnobody
1 July 2012 at 13:29
I saw it on release and a couple of times since, but Excalibur doesn't work for me - although I am something of a fan of Nicol Williamson (who was the best Hamlet I have ever seen).
1 July 2012 at 15:31