Google apps
Main menu

Post a Comment On: Bruce Charlton's Notions

1 – 8 of 8
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi, I have been wondering about this as well! The "Church" as an institution is corrupt and spiritually dead, just another corporation. Many Christians are realizing this and leaving the "Church," which is supposed to be the place where we see the spiritual gifts displayed. Instead, pastors and worship leaders are trying to be microcelebrities and rock stars. Instead of spiritual gifts, I see a social club of one-upmanship, and the Facebook mentality creeping into real life.

The extreme individualism in the West has led to a culture of competitive narcissism, so I agree that individuals having exceptional spiritual gifts might be too much of a temptation to gain fame and a following. Others also wouldn't be receptive to this type of gifting and would start trying to compete and "one-up" the spiritually gifted person. Maybe in the end time, our spiritual gifts will have more of a collective quality?

10 August 2018 at 19:50

Blogger William Wildblood said...

The only person I knew who had spiritual gifts in the old sense was almost embarrassed by them and almost never spoke of them. He took them to be a weighty responsibility and was very aware of the temptation to pride that they brought along with them.

Regarding your point about spiritual gifts of the modern era being more to do with the mind connecting to universal reality, I think this is correct. The old gifts are often observed in a rudimentary form in primitive societies which does rather imply that they belong to the past and a time when spirituality was seen as external to us.

11 August 2018 at 12:09

Blogger Bruce Charlton said...

@William - Yes, which is confirmed by the 'old style' spirital gifts still being frequently reported among recent converts in Africa, and indeed apparently in China.

11 August 2018 at 14:32

Blogger Chiu ChunLing said...

I take it as a commonplace that most spiritual gifts are indeed spiritual, and only perceivable to the spiritually sensitive.

The gift of tongues can result in a person audibly speaking a language more clearly and coherently than would be explicable by ordinary education. But more often it results in understanding through spiritual communion that is not dependent on correspondence of human language at all. A sudden miracle of contradiction of known medical principles while under observation of doctors and instruments is a possible manifestation of the gift of healing, but how much more often are those who trust in God more than doctors healed where no doctor is present to verify it? Even when healing is not so complete as would be convenient for our human desires, it can still be miraculous.

Prophesy and conversing with angels...of the latter I would say that it should be obviously impossible for that to be 'independently verified' by anyone not worthy to see angels. Even were the unworthy to physically see and hear an angel, all historical indications are that they will soon explain it away while denying the divine nature of the ministration. Prophesy encounters much the same problem...when the event was known to be prophesied by miraculous power, the faithless will do almost anything (including commission of monstrous crimes) to deny it has been fulfilled. When it is not known to be a prophesy by miraculous power, it will be dismissed as a lucky guess, if it is noticed at all.

In short, even recognizing the miraculousness of a miracle takes a spiritual gift. If we do not see miracles, the first gift we should seek is the gift of recognizing and acknowledging the miracles that are already around us. To the uninitiated this may seem like no more than an appreciation of the ethereal and eternal beauty of 'nature', 'simple life', or whatever. But if we are really thinking that we're just subjectively enjoying our own idiosyncratic perception of an illusion hung on random events, we are not to the point of being grateful for the marvelous works of Almighty God.

11 August 2018 at 14:50

Blogger Bruce Charlton said...

@CCL - Yes, human consciousness is not the same in all times and places - and modern Western man is blind to many things which are perceptible to most people in other times and places. For example, Western anthropologists have often been unable to perceive spiritual and magical phenomena that all present members of tribal people observed and experienced.

11 August 2018 at 15:44

Blogger The Crow said...

Humans seize upon everything that comes their way, intent upon leveraging it, and/or using it to exert control/power.
How would they even recognize spiritual gifts as such, in their clumsy haste to profit from them?

It's all absurdly simple, yet for humans, so devilishly fiendish in its elusiveness.
To recognize and realize that nothing is about them, or about humans, at all.

It is only about God.

13 August 2018 at 23:39

Blogger Chiu ChunLing said...

But to God, it is all about love for us.

14 August 2018 at 08:22

Blogger The Crow said...

Whereas to Christians, it is all about putting words in God's non-existent mouth, and speaking for God, on God's behalf, assuming that God is incapable of performing such trivial deeds for Himself.

14 August 2018 at 19:06