Cat vs. Kara: Who'd You Rather? Cat vs. Kara Who'd You Rather? 11/27/2009 9:30 AM PT Reality show host/judge Cat Deeley and Kara DioGuardi competed for face time at the same event in Beverly Hills the other night. Question is ... See Also Liza vs. Arlene: Who'd You Rather?Melinda vs. Nikki: Who'd You Rather? Share on Facebook Share on X Kara DioGuardi Cat Deeley Who'd You Rather?