Lizzy vs. Kirsten vs. Isla -- Who'd You Rather? Lizzy vs. Kirsten vs. Isla Who'd You Rather? 8/30/2012 4:00 AM PT "Bachelorette" babes Lizzy Caplan, Kirsten Dunst and Isla Fisher made nice at the film's premiere in Hollywood the other day. Question is ... More Who'd You Rather?Eva Amurri vs. Jaime King vs. Mandy MooreJoey Capponi vs. Louis VerdiJoel McHale vs. Ben Affleck Share on Facebook Share on X Lizzy Caplan Isla Fisher Kirsten Dunst Beauty Who'd You Rather?