Advertiser Disclosure
Our editorial team is committed to creating independent and objective content focused on helping our readers make informed decisions. To help support these efforts we receive compensation from companies that advertise with us.
The compensation we receive from these companies may impact how and where products appear on this site. This compensation does not influence the recommendations or advice our editorial team provides within our content. We do not include all companies, products or offers that may be available.
10 best roofing companies in Oyster Bay, New York
Alex HawkinsHome improvement writer
Alex Hawkins is a writer for USA TODAY Homefront. He has worked on consumer surveys with over 5...
Updated Aug. 5, 2024
Join more than 1,616 people who have received a quote in the last 30 days.
We've ranked the top 10 roofing companies that operate within 50 miles of Oyster Bay. We base our ranking off average customer ratings weighted against the number of reviews. For more information, check out our full methodology.
Roofs degrade as they age and must be repaired. Roofing contractors can replace shingles, repair leaks, install a new roof and reinforce your roof to prevent additional problems down the line. Roofing companies may also provide other services, such as gutter installation and siding replacement.
Roofing contractors usually need a license for roofing work, but the state of New York doesn't require one. Check with your city or county for local regulations.
Find the best roofing company for you in Oyster Bay
When evaluating roofing companies, check their ratings on review platforms, such as Google Reviews and Better Business Bureau (BBB), and choose one with a 3.5-star rating or higher.
Erie Home
Services offered
Highlights
- Quality customer service
- Transparent project updates
- Free inspections
Four Seasons Roofing
Services offered
Highlights
- Free inspections
- Customer education
- Transparent pricing
- Quality customer service
- Reputation for timeliness
Alexander Home Improvement Corporation
Services offered
Highlights
- Preventive services
Panther Siding & Windows Inc
Services offered
Highlights
- Preventive services
Express Home Improvements
Services offered
Highlights
- Transparent pricing
- Free inspections
- Quality customer service
- Honors appointment windows
Atlantic Exteriors Inc.
Services offered
Highlights
- Quality customer service
- Customer education
- Free inspections
Perfect Pitch Roofing
Services offered
Highlights
- Quality customer service
- Transparent pricing
- Free inspections
Roof Leak Enders: Roofing & Siding
Services offered
Highlights
- Preventive services
WD Builders Inc
Services offered
Highlights
- Reputation for timeliness
- Transparent project updates
- Quality customer service
- Transparent pricing
County Roofing Systems
Services offered
Highlights
- Preventive services
More providers
Below are additional roofing companies that didn’t make our top picks based on their distance, ratings or service offerings.
Clearview Roofing Huntington
Gibraltar Home Improvements
TCR BUILDERS
Brothers Aluminum
What is the cost of installing a new roof in Oyster Bay?
When you need to install a new roof, you should take time to select the best material. Each type of roofing has a different cost, durability and longevity. Metal, concrete and slate are among the most resilient roofing materials on the market.
Throughout the nation, the cost to install a slate roof on a 2,000-square-foot home comes in at around $29,563, compared to roughly $29,883 in Oyster Bay*.
*Local costs were determined using RSMeans project estimates combined with local labor costs from the Bureau of Labor Statistics and cost data from home improvement stores. We also interviewed homeowners from around the country to validate local costs.
How to save money on roof installation in Oyster Bay
New roof installation will typically be expensive, but there are ways you can save money on the service.
- Check your homeowners insurance: Consult your home insurance policy to determine whether it will help pay for the work that needs to be done. Depending on the reason for the damage, such as fallen branches or storms, your insurance policy may cover the cost of the new roof.
- Compare quotes from multiple sources: Compare the prices and services offered by several roofing contractors in Oyster Bay. This helps you make an informed decision.
- Conduct routine roof maintenance: After completing your repairs, you should prioritize regular inspections and maintenance on your roof. The prompt identification and fixing of minor issues can help prevent them from escalating into expensive problems.
- Invest in preventive measures: Look into preventive measures such as installing insulation and improved ventilation. These help reduce moisture damage and future repair needs while also lowering energy bills.
- Schedule roofing services during good weather if possible: Schedule your roof repairs during the milder seasons. Inclement weather may postpone work and increase costs. Contractors also tend to offer better pricing and discounts during off-peak periods. Do your best to schedule repairs for a period of dry weather during an off-peak season.
What are the signs that you need a new roof?
A professional roofer can inspect and repair or replace your roof. You may need to contact an expert if you spot the following:
- Water in your attic: If your attic insulation is wet or your roof has gaps, your roof likely needs repairs. Check your eaves for ice dams during winter, which can point to insufficient insulation or heat loss through the roof deck.
- Damaged shingles: Cracked, missing or curled shingles allow moisture into the roof, which can cause the decking and rafters to rot.
- Discoloration: Dark discoloration on the undersides of your rafters or decking means you probably have a leak and need to replace your roof.
- Mold or mildew Powdery mildew and mold is never a good sign. These can signify roof leaks and damage your health and home.
- Rust: Rust streaks from flashing or fasteners indicate deterioration, and rust and corrosion compromise weatherproofing and structural soundness.
- Visible sagging: Extra weight stress on roof joists, rafters and sheathing can cause visible sagging, a warning sign your roof may collapse. Reasons for extra weight can be overwhelmed drainage, concrete pavers, mechanical equipment, dense clay tiles or excess insulation. Warped sheathing can also make the problem worse by reducing your roof's drainage and causing ponding, pooling or standing water.
What are common roofing issues?
Even properly maintained roofs inevitably run into issues after years of wear. Catching issues early with visual inspections can prevent costly repairs later.
Some common issues to keep an eye out for during a visual inspection include the following.
Damaged shingles
One of the most frequent roofing issues you may encounter is damaged or worn shingles. While asphalt shingles generally last 20–30 years, exposure to harsh weather, wind, rain and ultraviolet radiation erodes them over time, leading to cracking or lifting. When shingles become broken or missing, moisture can seep into your roofing system, which can cause mold growth, leaks and deterioration within your home���s structure.
Flashing failures
Flashing—the metal sheets around a roof's vents, joints and dormers—redirects runoff away from vulnerable seams and transition points. Flashing failure is when water leaks into your home because of improper installation or deterioration. Check for flashing failure when you notice drips from ceilings that align with flashing seams, sagging areas, peeling paint, leaks coming from joints, or moisture stains.
Leaks
Your home may develop leaks in areas such as protrusions, seams and flashing around vent pipes, valleys, chimneys and skylights where roof planes meet. These watertight joints may shift and open gaps for water intrusion due to expansion and contraction from temperature changes. Detecting and fixing leaks as soon as possible is vital to avoid mildew, mold and decay.
Poor insulation
Attics with insufficient insulation cause extreme temperatures in your home, which causes problems such as ice dams, high energy bills, mold, damaged rafters and leaks. Making sure your attic is properly insulated for the local climate is a must for energy efficiency.
Standing water
Pooling water is common due to accumulated debris or low areas in your roof's decking. This can lead to pooled water after storms, which can be problematic. If present for 48 hours or more, moisture can saturate and rot your roof components. Weight stress is another consequence. Standing water can indicate the need to redo your roof surface to fix the drainage or slope. Clear debris regularly and ensure proper drainage to prevent these problems.
How long are roofs supposed to last?
Your climate, quality of installation, roofing material and maintenance frequency affect your roof's life expectancy. Installation quality is the most important factor. An improperly installed roof may have gaps or other issues that shorten its life span.
Generally, asphalt roofs have an average life span of 20–30 years. Architectural shingles can last longer, up to 25–30 years, in comparison with traditional three-tab shingles, which generally last around 15–20 years. Well-maintained shake roofs or wood shingles can last approximately 20–25 years. However, they may be susceptible to rot, insect damage and mold.
Slate, metal and concrete are some of the most durable roofing materials. Metal typically lasts 40–70 years or more. Concrete roofs generally last 50 years or up to a century with proper maintenance. Slate is one of the most durable materials, with slate roofs lasting for over a century.
Facts about Oyster Bay
Average Rainfall Summer
Average Rainfall Winter
Average Daily Sunlight
Best roof repair for you
Experts Ready to Help
How long are roofs supposed to last?
Your climate, quality of installation, roofing material and maintenance frequency affect your roof's life expectancy. Installation quality is the most important factor. An improperly installed roof may have gaps or other issues that shorten its life span.
Generally, asphalt roofs have an average life span of 20–30 years. Architectural shingles can last longer, up to 25–30 years, in comparison with traditional three-tab shingles, which generally last around 15–20 years. Well-maintained shake roofs or wood shingles can last approximately 20–25 years. However, they may be susceptible to rot, insect damage and mold.
Slate, metal and concrete are some of the most durable roofing materials. Metal typically lasts 40–70 years or more. Concrete roofs generally last 50 years or up to a century with proper maintenance. Slate is one of the most durable materials, with slate roofs lasting for over a century.
How to save money on roof installation in Oyster Bay
New roof installation will typically be expensive, but there are ways you can save money on the service.
- Check your homeowners insurance: Consult your home insurance policy to determine whether it will help pay for the work that needs to be done. Depending on the reason for the damage, such as fallen branches or storms, your insurance policy may cover the cost of the new roof.
- Compare quotes from multiple sources: Compare the prices and services offered by several roofing contractors in Oyster Bay. This helps you make an informed decision.
- Conduct routine roof maintenance: After completing your repairs, you should prioritize regular inspections and maintenance on your roof. The prompt identification and fixing of minor issues can help prevent them from escalating into expensive problems.
- Invest in preventive measures: Look into preventive measures such as installing insulation and improved ventilation. These help reduce moisture damage and future repair needs while also lowering energy bills.
- Schedule roofing services during good weather if possible: Schedule your roof repairs during the milder seasons. Inclement weather may postpone work and increase costs. Contractors also tend to offer better pricing and discounts during off-peak periods. Do your best to schedule repairs for a period of dry weather during an off-peak season.
Our methodology for selecting roof repair companies
The Homefront Local team employs a proprietary scoring algorithm that evaluates companies based on key factors you value, such as average customer review ratings and trustworthiness indicators. Our method for determining trust involves a comparative analysis of the number of reviews a company receives compared to its local competitors. This leads to companies that have earned more trust from your local community being awarded a higher score. We review national roofing companies against our full roofing methodology. We score roofing companies based on service options, reputation, additional services and customer satisfaction.
Editorial note: The name “Homefront” refers to the alliance between USA TODAY and Home Solutions that publishes review, comparison, and informational articles designed to help USA TODAY readers make smarter purchasing and investment decisions about their home. Under the alliance, Homefront provides and publishes research and articles about home service and home improvement topics. Homefront has an affiliate disclosure policy. The opinions, analyses, reviews or recommendations expressed in this article are those of the Homefront editorial staff alone (see About Homefront). Homefront adheres to strict editorial integrity standards. The information is believed to be accurate as of the publish date, but always check the provider’s website for the most current information. Go back to top
Our editors may use AI as an input tool to tailor information in local markets. All content goes through a rigorous research and review process led by our team of writers and editors.