Wet Hot American Newbies: The Fresh Faces Of ‘Ten Years Later’

Portrayed By: Sarah Burns
Where You’ve Seen Her: Big Little Lies, How to Get Away with Murder, Enlightened
Who Is Claire? Claire’s a Camp Firewood counselor from back in the day, duh. Don’t you remember her? She was there with her boyfriend Mark back in the summer of ’81, and J.J. (Zak Orth) had a total crush on her. She was totally there and not retroactively inserted into WHAS continuity.

Portrayed By: Mark Feuerstein
Where You’ve Seen Him: Royal Pains, Prison Break, Nurse Jackie
Who Is Mark? Okay, you can’t be fooled. Both Mark and Claire are new characters in Ten Years Later, but they’re old camp buds to everyone else in the cast. And while Claire has a little will they/won’t they tension with J.J., Mark’s a primo yuppie horndog that cheats on Claire nonstop.

Portrayed By: Jai Courtney
Where You’ve Seen Him: Suicide Squad, Divergent, Spartacus: War of the Damned
Who Is Garth? Susie (Amy Poehler) has traded up when it comes to boyfriends, moving from the closeted Ben (Bradley Cooper/Adam Scott) on to movie superstar Garth MacArthur. Garth is most known for his roles in Espresso Compresso and London Fog, and now the hunky actor is starring in Susie’s film By the Grace of God and Ever After.

Portrayed By: Rob Huebel
Where You’ve Seen Him: Transparent, Childrens Hospital, The League
Who Is Brodfard? Speaking of moving on, Shari (Beth Dover) has traded in Neil (Joe Lo Truglio) for a snooty Columbia professor. Bye-bye Camp Firewood, hello dates at Italian operas! With his cool car and flashy clothes, Brodfard is every bit as insufferable as his name implies.

Portrayed By: Alyssa Milano
Where You’ve Seen Her: Charmed, Melrose Place, Who’s the Boss?
Who Is Renata? In order to chillax during their camp reunion Ben and McKinley (Michael Ian Black) hired a nanny–Renata–to watch over their daughter. What McKinley and Ben don’t know is that they’ve gotten themselves involved in a whole Hand That Rocks the Cradle thing because Renata isn’t as stable as her agency suggested.

Portrayed By: Skyler Gisondo
Where You’ve Seen Him: Santa Clarita Diet, Vacation, Psych
Who Is Deegs? The only new camper we get to meet during Ten Years Later is Deegs, a too-cool bro that radiates a certain familiar slacker charisma. Yeah, he’s 1991’s version of Andy (Paul Rudd). This leads to a rivalry because, just like in Highlander, there can only be one!

Portrayed By: Anne-Marie Johnson
Where You’ve Seen Her: That’s So Raven, JAG, In the Heat of the Night
Who Is Ms. Burkhart? President Ronald Reagan (Michael Showalter) is back in action in Ten Years Later (along with Bush and Clinton). Ms. Burkhart does Reagan’s dirty work, work that includes trying to buy Camp Firewood from Beth (Janeane Garofalo).

Portrayed By: Maya Erskine
Where You’ve Seen Her: Casual, Insecure, Man Seeking Woman
Who Is Ginny? In the ten years since that unforgettable (and, at times, deadly) summer at Camp Firewood, Coop (Showalter) has moved on from his crush on Katie (Marguerite Moreau) and gotten engaged to Ginny. There’s just one problem: Ginny doesn’t really get the magic of Camp Firewood, y’know?

Portrayed By: Ava Acres
Where You’ve Seen Her: Handsome: A Netflix Mystery Movie, Crazy Ex-Girlfriend, American Horror Story: Hotel
Who Is Jenny? Who is Jenny? Look at her! Isn’t it obvious? Okay–Jenny (yes, there’s both a Ginny and a Jenny in Ten Years Later) is Gail’s (Molly Shannon) daughter. And, considering the sleeveless tee and bandana, Jenny is obviously the daughter of Gene, the shellshocked camp chef played by Christopher Meloni.

Portrayed By: Kerry O’Malley and Dax Shepard
Where You’ve Seen Her: The Last Tycoon, Annabelle, Shameless
Where You’ve Seen Him: Parenthood, Without a Paddle, Punk’d
Who Are Darla and Mikey? The mysterious Darla and Mikey, a suburban couple living with the elderly Vivian Larson, play a pivotal role in Lindsay’s (Elizabeth Banks) mission to uncover the connection between Ronald Reagan and Camp Firewood. Or do they?

Portrayed By: Marlo Thomas
Where You’ve Seen Her: Friends, Free to Be… You & Me, That Girl
Who Is Vivian? Television icon Marlo Thomas gets deep into character as the elderly (and also, at times, creepy) Vivian Larson. While Mikey and Darla want nothing to do with Linday’s investigation, it’s Vivian that wants to blow the whole conspiracy wide open! Her connection to this mystery, it turns out, goes all the way to the top. Or does it?

Where to stream Wet Hot American Summer: Ten Years Later