Mary-Kate and Ashley talk first kisses and singing skills on 'Ellen'

Spent your youth trying to decide whether you were a Mary-Kate or an Ashley? (My hand is raised.) If so, Ellen DeGeneres has a treat for you (read: us).

In an episode of Ellen that airs today, DeGeneres hands each Olsen twin a double-sided paddle. One side reads “her;” the other, “me.” DeGeneres proceeds to ask the twins questions like, “who’s messier?” (both are messy) and “who can talk their way out of a parking ticket?” (Mary-Kate). Despite their childhood singing careers, though, both refuse to tell Ellen which of them is the better singer. As a matter of fact, admits Ashley, “I don’t think we’re very good singers.” Guess we won’t be hearing an updated version of classic “Gimme Pizza” anytime soon.

Watch the full clip below: