Guilt exclusive clip stars Anthony Head

Seeing as Father’s Day was just yesterday, it’s only appropriate that Monday night’s episode of Guilt include some father-stepdaughter moments, albeit some seriously shady ones. This is a show about a murdered girl, after all.

In the exclusive clip above, we see Grace and Natalie Atwood reunited with their stepfather James (or, in an alternative way of looking at it, we see Buffy the Vampire Slayer‘s Anthony Head reunited with his real-life daughter Daisy, who plays Grace). He’s showering them with gifts, an act that provokes opposite responses from the two women. Grace, who’s not letting murder accusations keep her from a nice meal and good time, is thrilled with her fancy new purse, while her older sister is ready to give James the third degree.

Initially, Natalie concedes when questioning James about his recent visit to London, but then she has to ask: “So, did you two get together when you were here a few weeks ago, go out for dinner?”

“I’m sorry, honey. I flew in for a meeting and left the next morning,” James responded on the spot, looking at Grace. “I just figured for once I wouldn’t ask you to entertain the good geezer.”

“You didn’t have time to see Grace, but you went to the theater?” That Natalie, she’s a quick one!

Guilt airs Mondays at 9 p.m. on Freeform.